Most obscure 'American Idol' albums

George Huff, 'Miracles'

The last male contestant eliminated from season three has since gone on to carve himself a niche as sort of a skinnier, less talented Ruben Studdard, releasing this R&B/gospel album to modest sales and respectable reviews. The fact that he even made it to the finals might be the biggest “Miracle” of all; he was actually eliminated in the first round but got reinstated to the semifinals when another contestant, Donnie Williams, was disqualified over a drunk driving charge. His original label, Word Records, dropped him after "Miracles" sold poorly; undeterred, Huff is releasing a second, self-titled album later this year.